Avoid These Common Car Buying Pitfalls
Buying a car is exciting, but making a wrong decision can cost you thousands of dollars. Whether you’re purchasing new or used, leasing, or financing, being informed can help you negotiate better deals, avoid scams, and choose the right car for your needs.
This guide will walk you through 35 costly mistakes buyers make—and how to avoid them in 2025. 🚗💨
1. Not Comparing Prices
Many buyers only visit one dealership—a big mistake. Dealers set their own prices, meaning you can find the same car for a lower cost elsewhere.
✔ What to Do:
Instant. Simple. Smart
We Make Insurance Easy
Find Out How Much You Can Save Today
Take the first step towards peace of mind with LoPriore’s team. Experience tailored insurance solutions that fit your lifestyle and budget. Get your free, no-obligation quote today and see the difference expertise makes!
- Compare prices at multiple dealerships online using Edmunds, Kelley Blue Book, and Cars.com.
- Use the lowest price as leverage at your preferred dealer.
2. Ignoring Your Trade-In Value
Dealerships undervalue trade-ins to maximize their profit. If you don’t research your car’s value, you could lose thousands.
✔ What to Do:
- Check your car’s market value using Kelley Blue Book (KBB) or Carvana.
- Consider selling privately for a better price.
3. Not Shopping for a Loan Beforehand
Many dealerships mark up interest rates on loans. Accepting their first offer could cost you thousands over time.
✔ What to Do:
- Get pre-approved by a credit union or online lender to compare rates.
- Aim for a lower APR to save money over your loan term.
Car Loan Interest Rate Impact Over Time
Loan Amount | Interest Rate (APR) | Loan Term | Monthly Payment | Total Interest Paid |
$25,000 | 3.50% | 60 Months | $455 | $2,294 |
$25,000 | 5.00% | 60 Months | $472 | $3,342 |
$25,000 | 7.00% | 60 Months | $496 | $4,764 |
$25,000 | 9.00% | 60 Months | $518 | $6,092 |
Key Takeaway: Even a 1.5% difference in APR can cost you over $1,000 more in interest payments!
4. Focusing Only on Monthly Payments
Dealers manipulate monthly payments to hide higher costs. A lower monthly bill often means a longer loan and higher interest.
✔ What to Do:
- Focus on total cost, not just the payment amount.
- Use a car loan calculator (Bankrate Calculator) to see the true cost over time.
5. Ignoring Future Resale Value
Not all cars hold their value well. If you plan to sell or trade-in later, picking the wrong model could cost you.
✔ What to Do:
- Research depreciation rates on sites like Consumer Reports.
- Luxury brands and certain electric vehicles (EVs) often lose value faster.
6. Rushing Through the Process
Buying a car should take time. If you rush, you might miss out on better deals or overlook hidden costs.
✔ What to Do:
- Take at least a week to shop around.
- Avoid pressure tactics from salespeople.
7. Not Considering Electric Vehicles (EVs)
Gas prices fluctuate, and EVs are growing in popularity. Ignoring them might cost you fuel savings.
✔ What to Do:
- Check if federal/state tax credits apply to EVs.
- Compare charging costs to gas expenses before deciding.
8. Forgetting About Online Car Buying Options
You don’t need to buy from a traditional dealer. Platforms like Carvana, Vroom, and Tesla Direct let you purchase cars entirely online.
✔ What to Do:
- Consider online options for no-haggle pricing and home delivery.
- Read reviews to ensure the platform is reputable.
9. Overlooking Hidden Fees
The final price isn’t just the sticker price. Dealers add processing fees, warranties, and add-ons that inflate costs.
✔ What to Do:
- Ask for a breakdown of ALL fees before signing.
- Negotiate unnecessary fees out of the deal.
10. Not Checking the Vehicle History (Used Cars)
A used car may look perfect but have hidden damage or previous accidents.
✔ What to Do:
- Always check Carfax or AutoCheck reports before buying.
- Get a mechanic’s inspection for added protection.
11. Buying Without Test Driving
A car might look great on paper, but skipping the test drive can lead to unexpected dissatisfaction.
✔ What to Do:
- Test drive on both highways and city streets.
- Check for blind spots, braking response, and comfort.
12. Overlooking Pre-Purchase Inspections (Used Cars)
For used cars, skipping a pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic can lead to costly repairs down the line.
✔ What to Do:
- Have a third-party mechanic inspect any used car.
- Avoid cars with frame damage or flood history.
13. Falling for the First Deal
Jumping on the first price offered might mean missing out on a better deal elsewhere.
✔ What to Do:
- Get multiple dealer quotes before making a decision.
- Negotiate even if the price seems fair.
14. Neglecting Financing Options
Accepting dealership financing without shopping around can lead to higher interest rates.
✔ What to Do:
- Compare loans from banks, credit unions, and online lenders.
- Watch out for hidden fees or early payoff penalties.
15. Being Swayed by Upsells
Dealerships often push extra features, warranties, and insurance products at high markups.
✔ What to Do:
- Stick to your budget and decline unnecessary add-ons.
- Research third-party warranty providers if needed.
16. Not Considering Future Needs
Buying a car that only fits your current situation might lead to early buyer’s remorse.
✔ What to Do:
- Think about family expansion, lifestyle changes, and resale value.
- Choose a car that suits your long-term needs.
17. Overlooking Fuel Efficiency
Ignoring a car’s fuel economy can result in higher running costs.
✔ What to Do:
- Check MPG ratings and consider hybrid or EV options.
- Factor in fuel costs over time.
18. Ignoring Lease-End Costs
If leasing, unexpected fees at the end of the term can be expensive.
✔ What to Do:
- Know your lease’s mileage limits and wear-and-tear policies.
- Budget for end-of-lease charges.
19. Not Reading the Fine Print
Skipping the terms and conditions can lock you into unwanted obligations.
✔ What to Do:
- Read every line of the contract before signing.
- Watch for hidden fees and cancellation clauses.
20. Impulse Buying
Falling in love with a car without research can lead to overspending.
✔ What to Do:
- Step back, compare options, and sleep on it before buying.
- Stick to your budget and research plan.
21. Skipping Manufacturer Rebates
Many manufacturers offer special rebates and incentives, but dealers won’t always tell you.
✔ What to Do:
- Check the manufacturer’s website for current promotions.
- Ask the dealer about cashback offers and loyalty discounts.
22. Not Asking for Dealer Incentives
Dealerships often have hidden incentives from manufacturers, but they may not disclose them upfront.
✔ What to Do:
- Ask directly: “Are there any manufacturer incentives available on this model?”
- Research regional incentives using sites like Edmunds or TrueCar.
23. Being Swayed by Extended Warranties
Dealerships push extended warranties at a high markup, often making huge profits.
✔ What to Do:
- Compare dealer warranties with third-party providers.
- Only purchase if it makes financial sense based on the car’s reliability.
24. Failing to Negotiate the Trade-In
Dealerships lowball trade-in offers to maximize their profits.
✔ What to Do:
- Get multiple offers from CarMax, Carvana, or local dealerships before accepting one.
- Use online tools like KBB Instant Cash Offer to estimate your car’s worth.
25. Forgetting About Vehicle Registration Fees
State and local registration fees can add hundreds to your purchase cost.
✔ What to Do:
- Research registration costs in your state before finalizing your budget.
- Factor in title transfer and sales tax costs.
26. Ignoring Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Options
A Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) vehicle often offers warranty coverage and reliability checks at a much lower price than a new car.
✔ What to Do:
- Consider CPO options from manufacturers instead of buying new.
- Look for low-mileage vehicles with extended warranties.
Comparison of New vs. Used vs. Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Vehicles
Feature | New Car | Used Car | Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) |
Price | Highest | Lowest | Mid-range |
Warranty | Full Manufacturer Warranty | Varies (Often None) | Extended Manufacturer Warranty |
Depreciation | Highest in First 3 Years | Slower | Slower Than New |
Maintenance Costs | Lower Initially | Can be Higher | Lower Due to Inspection |
Financing Rates | Often Lower | Higher Rates | Often Lower than Used |
Peace of Mind | High | Varies | High |
27. Not Researching Safety Ratings
Some cars look great but have poor crash-test ratings or lack advanced safety features.
✔ What to Do:
- Check safety ratings on NHTSA and IIHS websites.
- Look for features like automatic braking and blind-spot monitoring.
28. Overpaying for Unnecessary Features
High-tech add-ons, built-in navigation, and premium sound systems can increase costs significantly.
✔ What to Do:
- Determine which features you actually need.
- Consider using aftermarket options like Google Maps or Apple CarPlay.
29. Buying a Car That Doesn’t Fit Your Needs
Choosing a car based on looks or trends can lead to regret later.
✔ What to Do:
- Consider your driving habits, family size, and future needs.
- Test different models to find the best fit.
30. Not Understanding Lease Terms
Leasing can seem attractive, but hidden fees and mileage limits can cost you.
✔ What to Do:
- Read your lease agreement carefully for mileage restrictions and penalties.
- Calculate if leasing is actually cheaper than buying.
Lease vs. Buy Cost Comparison
Cost Factor | Leasing a Car | Buying a Car |
Monthly Payments | Lower | Higher |
Mileage Limits | Yes (Usually 10,000-15,000 per year) | No |
Ownership | No (You return it) | Yes (Yours after loan) |
Upfront Costs | Usually lower | Higher (Down Payment, Taxes) |
Long-Term Costs | Higher (Always Have a Payment) | Lower (Once Paid Off) |
Customization | Limited | Unlimited |
Key Takeaway: Leasing is great for low-mileage drivers who want a new car every few years, while buying is better for long-term savings.
31. Not Factoring in Maintenance Costs
Some cars have higher maintenance and repair costs, which can quickly add up.
✔ What to Do:
- Research average repair costs on CarMD or Edmunds.
- Consider reliability ratings when choosing a brand.
32. Disregarding Depreciation Rates
New cars lose value quickly, and some depreciate faster than others.
✔ What to Do:
- Check depreciation rates on Edmunds or KBB.
- Avoid models known for high depreciation if resale value matters to you.
Depreciation Rates of Common Vehicle Types
Vehicle Type | Depreciation After 1 Year | Depreciation After 3 Years | Depreciation After 5 Years |
Economy Car | 20% | 45% | 60% |
SUV | 18% | 40% | 55% |
Luxury Car | 25% | 55% | 70% |
Electric Vehicle (EV) | 30% | 50% | 65% |
Hybrid Car | 15% | 35% | 50% |
Truck | 12% | 30% | 45% |
Key Takeaway: Luxury cars and EVs often have the highest depreciation, while trucks and hybrids hold their value better over time.
33. Not Checking the Warranty Coverage
Some cars come with limited warranties, and coverage varies by brand.
✔ What to Do:
- Review what’s included in the factory warranty.
- Ask about bumper-to-bumper vs. powertrain coverage.
34. Overlooking Loan Prepayment Penalties
Some auto loans charge penalties for early payoff, increasing your total cost.
✔ What to Do:
- Read your loan terms to see if prepayment is allowed.
- Choose a lender that doesn’t penalize early payoff.
35. Forgetting About Personal Comfort and Ergonomics
A car might check all the boxes but still feel uncomfortable to drive.
✔ What to Do:
- Sit in the car for at least 15 minutes before deciding.
- Check seat comfort, visibility, and dashboard layout.
Final Thoughts: Buy Smart, Save Big
By avoiding these 35 common mistakes, you can save money, stress, and time when purchasing your next car.
Want to protect your new ride with the best insurance rates? Get a Free Quote Today ✅
Live Securely
Get an Insurance Quote Today!
Enjoying your lifestyle? Make sure it’s protected. Click below to get a quick quote from LoPriore Insurance.