Auto Insurance and Tariffs: 5 Shocking Ways They Affect You

Auto insurance and tariffs
Table of Contents

The new wave of tariffs on imported vehicles and car parts is more than just a headline — it’s reshaping the way Americans drive, repair, and insure their cars. Whether you’re looking to buy a new vehicle or just trying to maintain the one you already own, tariffs could influence your expenses more than you realize.

This article dives into how auto insurance and tariffs intersect, what Massachusetts drivers can expect, and how to protect yourself from rising costs.

How New Tariffs Impact Auto Insurance Rates

Tariffs on imported vehicles and auto parts can significantly influence how much you pay for auto insurance — and not in a good way.

When tariffs increase the price of cars or parts, insurers take on higher costs when paying claims. For example, if a bumper now costs 30% more because it’s imported, the overall cost to repair your vehicle increases. Insurance companies then adjust their rates based on these rising repair costs.

Instant. Simple. Smart
We Make Insurance
Easy

Find Out How Much You Can Save Today

Take the first step towards peace of mind with LoPriore’s team. Experience tailored insurance solutions that fit your lifestyle and budget. Get your free, no-obligation quote today and see the difference expertise makes!

  • Increased premiums for comprehensive and collision coverage
  • Revised underwriting standards to account for higher vehicle and repair values
  • Higher rates for imported brands like Toyota, Honda, and Subaru

These changes may hit even faster in Massachusetts, where car insurance is already expensive.

Are Repair Costs About to Skyrocket?

Yes — and that has a direct effect on both out-of-pocket expenses and claims processing.

Tariffs on parts mean higher material costs for auto body shops, which impacts:

  • Labor timelines and part availability
  • Costs for OEM vs. aftermarket parts
  • Extended rental car use and slower claims

If you rely on rental reimbursement coverage, be sure your limits are sufficient — delays could cost you more than expected.

Why Insurers Might Total Your Car More Often

With rising repair costs, more vehicles are crossing the “total loss” threshold. This can lead to:

  • Loan balances higher than insurance payouts
  • More expensive or limited replacement options
  • Loss of preferred features in a replacement vehicle

Protect yourself with gap insurance if you lease or finance your car. It helps cover the difference between your loan balance and the settlement amount.

Can I Avoid a Rate Increase on My Auto Insurance?

While you can’t stop tariffs, you can take action to minimize the impact on your policy:

  • Increase your deductible to lower your premium
  • Drop collision or comprehensive coverage on older cars
  • Bundle policies (home, auto) to save
  • Explore telematics and safe-driver discounts
  • Shop your policy annually with independent agents like LoPriore

Massachusetts Drivers: Here’s What You Need to Know

Massachusetts drivers are uniquely vulnerable to tariff impacts:

  • Popular brands are import-heavy (Toyota, Honda, Subaru)
  • Harsh winters increase part wear and repair frequency
  • Potholes, traffic, and mileage increase maintenance needs

Tariffs could make everything from routine repairs to accident claims more expensive. Review your policy now to avoid this.

How This Affects Used vs. New Car Insurance

Tariffs affect new and used cars differently. Here’s how:

New Cars

  • Likely to reflect tariffs in MSRP
  • Higher premiums due to value
  • Risk of parts delays during repairs

Used Cars

  • Usually tariff-exempt, but rising in demand
  • Still affected by repair complexity and availability
  • Older parts may be hard to source

Always request an insurance quote before buying, to understand full ownership costs.

Planning Ahead: Tips to Stay Protected

  • Review your policy annually
  • Use affordability calculators and VIN tools
  • Speak with a local independent agent
  • Adjust rental reimbursement limits
  • Keep your vehicle well maintained

Related Resources

FAQs

How do tariffs influence auto insurance?

Tariffs increase the cost of vehicles and parts, which raises claims costs and can lead to higher insurance premiums.

Will my insurance cover tariff-related repair delays?

Only if you have rental reimbursement coverage — check your policy limits to ensure you’re covered during long wait times.

Do used cars offer better insurance rates?

Sometimes. Used cars may be cheaper to insure, but demand, age, and repair costs can still influence premiums.

What’s the best way to save on auto insurance?

Shop around annually, bundle policies, and consider usage-based insurance options that reward safe driving.

Should I wait to buy a car?

If you’re not in a rush, waiting for pricing to stabilize might be wise. If you buy now, consider vehicles with more U.S.-sourced components.

Conclusion

Tariffs are changing more than car prices—they’re reshaping how we insure and repair our vehicles. For Massachusetts drivers, staying ahead of these shifts means reviewing their insurance, understanding their vehicle’s sourcing, and being proactive with policy updates.

Don’t wait for your premium to spike before taking action. Contact LoPriore Insurance today and let our team help you make informed decisions and save money in a shifting market.

Your One Stop Shop For Auto Insurance
Compare and Save Today

It’s super easy and quick! Get fast auto insurance quotes -Click below to get started

Are You Paying Too Much For Insurance?

Talk with an Agent and see how we can help you save!

loPriore-logo.svg